Wavelet SOS Notebook

Theorems & Proofs

Mathematical results used in the research journal, with proofs and source notes.

Corollary 1.1

Hermitian sums of squares on the two-torus

Let p∈ℂ[z1±1,z2±1]p \in \mathbb C[z_1^{\pm1},z_2^{\pm1}] be real-valued and nonnegative on 𝕋2\mathbb T^2, where 𝕋={z∈ℂ:|z|=1}\mathbb T=\{z\in\mathbb C:|z|=1\}. There are finitely many ordinary polynomials h1,…,hr∈ℂ[z1,z2]h_1,\ldots,h_r \in \mathbb C[z_1,z_2] such that p(z)=∑j=1r|hj(z)|2(z∈𝕋2). p(z)=\sum_{j=1}^r |h_j(z)|^2 \qquad (z\in\mathbb T^2).

Proof

Proof using Scheiderer’s surface theorem. Write zk=xk+iykz_k=x_k+i y_k. The product VV of the two affine unit circles xk2+yk2=1x_k^2+y_k^2=1 is a nonsingular integral affine real surface with compact real locus 𝕋2\mathbb T^2. Replace zkz_k and zk−1z_k^{-1} in pp by xk+iykx_k+i y_k and xk−iykx_k-i y_k, respectively. Taking the real part of the resulting polynomial gives an element f∈ℝ[V]f\in\mathbb R[V] whose values on V(ℝ)V(\mathbb R) agree with pp.

Since f≥0f\geq0 on V(ℝ)V(\mathbb R), Scheiderer’s theorem gives f=∑j=1rgj2f=\sum_{j=1}^r g_j^2 with gj∈ℝ[V]g_j\in\mathbb R[V]. In each gjg_j, substitute xk=zk+zk−12,yk=zk−zk−12i. x_k=\frac{z_k+z_k^{-1}}2,\qquad y_k=\frac{z_k-z_k^{-1}}{2i}. The resulting Laurent polynomial ℓj\ell_j is real-valued on 𝕋2\mathbb T^2, so ℓj2=|ℓj|2\ell_j^2=|\ell_j|^2 there. For each jj, choose nonnegative integers aj,bja_j,b_j large enough that hj=z1ajz2bjℓjh_j=z_1^{a_j}z_2^{b_j}\ell_j is an ordinary polynomial. The multiplying monomial has modulus one on 𝕋2\mathbb T^2, hence |hj|=|ℓj||h_j|=|\ell_j| there. Summing gives the asserted identity. ∎

Proof provenance

The coordinate substitutions and the monomial shifts give the notebook’s deduction of the corollary. The existence of the elements gjg_j is the step supplied by Scheiderer’s surface theorem.

Open question for this notebook

Given the coefficients of pp, how can we compute suitable factors? Once the Laurent factors are available, the final monomial shifts can be read directly from their supports.

Source

Claus Scheiderer, “Sums of squares on real algebraic surfaces” (2006), Corollary 3.4, restated by the author as Theorem 3.3.1 in “Positivity and sums of squares: a guide to recent results,” PDF p. 28. Author’s restatement · Original paper

Review scope

The independent reviewer checked the author’s restatement and the deduction on the torus. A proof of the underlying surface theorem is a separate reading task.